Written and pictorial explanations of physical equilibrium generated by experts and novices

CHED 3

Sevil Akaygun, sevil.akaygun@gmail.com, School of Chemistry, Earth Sciences and Physics, University of Northern Colorado, 1312 9th Avenue # 22, Greeley, CO 80631 and Loretta Jones, Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Northern Colorado, 510 20th St., Greeley, CO 80639.
In chemistry classes, teachers make use of verbal and pictorial explanations. These two kinds of explanations may emphasize different aspects of the same topic. In addition, experts and novices usually differ in terms of the characteristics of written and pictorial explanations that reveal their mental models. Novices have been found to focus on available static components whereas experts use integrated structural, functional and behavioral elements to describe a dynamic system. In this study, experts (chemistry professors, lecturers, and high school teachers), intermediates (chemistry graduate students) and novices (high school and college students in introductory chemistry courses) were asked to write or draw explanations for liquid-vapor equilibrium. Key features of the written and drawn explanations generated by the experts and novices were then compared. The results of the study and the implications for the teaching of chemistry will be discussed.
 

Research in Chemical Education
8:30 AM-11:35 AM, Sunday, March 25, 2007 McCormick Place North -- Room N227A, Level 2, Oral

Division of Chemical Education

The 233rd ACS National Meeting, Chicago, IL, March 25-29, 2007